Foster on Film

The Film Criticism of Matthew M. Foster
  • Home
  • The Important Films
    • Film Noir
    • Swashbucklers
    • Science Fiction
    • British Comedy
  • The Great Films
    • Fixing the Oscars
      • The 1930s
      • The 1940s
      • The 1950s
      • The 1960s
    • The Best Films By The Great Actors
    • The Best Films By The Great Directors
    • The Not-So-Great
  • Reviews
    • Fantasy
    • Film Noir
    • Horror
      • Asian
      • Christian Mythos
      • Classic Horror
      • Demons
      • Ghost Stories
      • Giant Monsters
        • Godzilla
      • Mad Scientists
      • Mummies
      • Old Dark House
      • Poverty Row
      • Slashers
      • Vampires
      • Werewolves
      • Zombies
    • Post-War British Comedy
    • Science Fiction
      • Aliens
      • Cyberpunk
      • Mad Scientists
      • Post-Apocalyptic
      • Space Opera
    • Superhero
    • Swashbucklers
    • Other Reviews
      • Fan Edits
      • Holiday Films
        • Christmas
        • Christmastime
        • Xmas Shorts
        • Halloween
      • Musicals
      • Shakespeare
      • Miscellaneous
  • Rankings/Lists

Captain America: The Winter Soldier (2014) [MCU Ranking]

Feb 272014
 
five reels

Captain America 2

Captain America teams up with Black Widow to uncover a conspiracy at the highest levels of government while also meeting an old friend who’s become a killing machine.

Where Captain America: The First Avenger felt like a 1950s war movie, The Winter Solder feels like a 1970s spy thriller, just with a lot more exploding flying ships. While some MCU films have aimed low and avoided heavier thematic elements, the second solo outing for Captain America goes for broke, and wins. The story is complex, but makes sense and is easy to follow. Steve Rogers goes through substantial changes, and lets us examine the meanings of freedom, safety, and tyranny, though him, and how these three things overlap in uncomfortable ways. The movie does all that while delivering an almost excessive amount of action and slipping into buddy movie mode from time to time. It also introduces a new hero in Falcon, as well as two of the better villains.

I didn’t think Marvel could pull off one good Captain America movie. Two was a shock. It seems, with good writing, clear directing, and the right star, an old fashioned hero can work in his own time, and in our times, commenting on both.

 Reviews, Superhero Tagged with: Five Reels

Recent Reviews

  • Sinners (2025)
  • The Mummy (1932)
  • Alien: Romulus (2024)
  • Near Dark (1987)
  • Phantom of the Opera (1943)
  • The Climax (1944)
  • The Monster and the Girl (1941)
  • The Catman of Paris (1946)
  • The Leopard Man (1943)
  • The Return of the Vampire (1944)
<center>SEE MORE →</center>

Review Scale

(A Classic)
(See It)
(Matinee)
(Wait for TV)
(Skip It)
(Toxic)

Box Office Results

About

About Me

Links

  • Dragon Con Film Festival
  • Eugie Foster.com
  • IMDB.com
  • Movie Review Index
  • Short of the Week
  • The Devil's Reviews
  • The Film Atheist

Contact Me

Contact Me
Site design by Eugie Foster
All Rights Reserved
Suffusion theme by Sayontan Sinha